Thanksgiving is one of my favorite holidays. Great food, the people you love around one table, the kids home from college, and not a single gift to wrap.
If you’re hosting this year, or have hosted in the past, you know the cost of putting on a Thanksgiving meal can add up fast. A turkey, a handful of sides, pies, drinks, and the extra butter you forgot you needed. With food prices as high as they are, feeding a big group is a real expense.
The good news is there are steps you can start taking now that will lower your costs without sacrificing quality. None of them are complicated. Most are about getting organized early and paying attention at the store. Many will also save you time and reduce stress, so you can be fully present and enjoy the day with the people you love. Because after all, the day is about much more than the food. ❤️
Here are 12 ways we’ve learned to bring the cost down.
1. Skip the specialty turkey
Instead of buying your turkey at a specialty store or placing a special order, check out your local grocery store. If you need a 20-pound turkey for a crowd, the bird can be a big part of your total bill.
Some of our best Thanksgiving turkeys have come from our local grocery store, and they were just as good as the years we ordered from an expensive specialty shop. The difference in taste was not noticable. The difference in price was.
Grocery stores also tend to price turkeys low this time of year to bring shoppers in so you buy all the other parts of your meal with them. Last year, the American Farm Bureau Federation found the average 16-pound frozen turkey cost $21.50, or about $1.34 per pound, down more than 16% from the year before. This is far less than you will pay for a specialty order. Check your store’s flyer, compare prices at a few local stores, and look for a free or discounted turkey when you spend a certain amount.
Besides, with all the beautiful sides on the table, the meal is about the whole experience, not just the turkey.
2. Don’t oversize everything (starting with the turkey)
When you’re hosting, it’s natural to buy more of everything, just in case. I still struggle with this one. The thought of someone scraping the bottom of the mashed potato bowl because I didn’t make enough sends chills down my spine!
But how many times have you dumped out half a bowl of mashed potatoes or carrots because you planned for too much food? Food is too expensive to throw away.
Start with the turkey. The USDA recommends about one pound per person (source), so for 10 guests, a 10- to 12-pound bird is plenty. Then apply the same thinking to the sides. Make enough for a full plate and seconds, not enough for 7 nights of leftovers.
3. Make one complete list, and stick to it
Going into a grocery store without a list almost always means spending more than you planned. For a major holiday, an organized list matters even more.
Think through every part of the meal: appetizers, the main course, sides, desserts, and drinks. Then add the things people forget, like paper goods, foil pans, pantry staples, and everything you need to make the gravy or sauces. Check your pantry and fridge, cross off what you already have, and get everything onto one list.
A complete list also means you won’t be running back to the store over and over in the days before Thanksgiving. And we all know what happens when we run in just for whipped cream. We end up adding a bit of this and that, a few more cheeses for the cheese tray we don’t need, or those cute little chocolate turkeys up by the register. (And yes, I know. They’re so cute, and they graced my table one year)
4. Build your list around the sales flyer
Start early. For the next week or two, check your local store’s flyer. In the weeks before Thanksgiving, flyers are full of deals on the essentials: frozen turkeys, spices, baking supplies, pumpkin puree, squash, cranberries, and drinks.
These specials are running now, and buying a little each week helps you save and spreads the cost out. Watch for limited-time promotions, buy-one-get-one-free offers, and discounts when you buy more.
Shopping the specials takes an extra step, but in our experience it can save 20 to 25% on many of the items on your list. It’s also exactly what we do every week at The Dinner Daily. We build each member’s dinner menu around the sales at their own grocery store, because shopping the flyer is one of the simplest ways to spend less without eating any less well.
5. Go store brand on the basics
Nobody at your table can taste the difference between name-brand and store-brand chicken broth. The same goes for butter, canned goods if you are using them, sugar, flour, and stuffing mix.
Save the name brands for the one or two things your family truly cares about, and let the store brand handle the rest.
6. Buy your wine by the case
One of our favorite Thanksgiving money-saving tips is to buy your wine by the case. When we asked a few local wine and liquor stores, 25% off a case was a common offer, and many let you mix and match. If your store doesn’t offer a case discount, try a different one.
It costs more up front, but it saves a good chunk of money over the whole holiday season. Most of us go to several gatherings between now and New Year’s, so having bottles on hand means you’re ready for hostess gifts and parties without a last-minute stop on the way. Grab a few wine gift bags while you’re at it, and you’ll always be prepared.
A standard bottle pours about five glasses, so you can do the math from your guest list.
7. Plan the other dinners that week, too
This is the one almost nobody talks about. Thanksgiving week isn’t just one big meal. It’s also Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday, when you’re shopping, chopping, and cleaning the house, and nobody has thought about dinner.
That’s when the takeout orders start, and they add up fast. Plan two or three simple dinners for the days before Thanksgiving, the kind you can make without thinking. Your wallet and your sanity will both thank you.
8. Plan for one or two leftover meals, and that’s it
Leftovers are part of the fun. But after a few rounds of Thanksgiving leftovers, I start craving something completely different, like a crisp garden salad with some salmon. No sauces, no butter.
So plan for one or two leftover meals, not a week’s worth. Maybe enough turkey for a soup or a casserole, and that’s it. Decide ahead of time what the leftovers will become, so they actually get eaten instead of sitting in the fridge and dumped out later.
9. Ask for help now, and decide who’s bringing what
Once your list is together, decide what you’re buying and what you’ll ask guests to bring. That could be a fully prepared side, or smaller things like wine, non-alcoholic drinks, desserts, rolls, or festive paper goods. These small things add up in both cost and time, and most people like to help. Giving guests plenty of notice makes it simple for them to say yes.
Be sure to tell them how many people their dish needs to serve. You don’t want a table of 12 with only enough mashed potatoes for six.
Then highlight the items on your master list that guests are bringing, so you can skip them at the store. You could keep two lists (“what I’m doing” and “what others are bringing”), but I’ve found one complete list keeps everything more organized.
10. Keep the sides to the favorites
Do you really need six to eight sides? Many of us feel like we have to fill the table. One year I made nine, and it was crazy and exhausting. Don’t ever do that.
I love trying new recipes around the holidays, but I’ve learned that making a recipe for the first time on Thanksgiving isn’t always the best idea. Focus on the tried and true, the sides your family loves and looks forward to every year. They’re also the recipes you can make almost on autopilot, which makes the whole day simpler. Save new recipes for a smaller crowd or another holiday meal.
If you must, limit yourself to one new dish. The “world’s best stuffing” will always be tempting, but I’ve found it’s best to keep it simple.
Fewer sides also naturally lower your grocery bill. They also set you up for a more relaxed day, where you can join the conversation instead of being glued to the stovetop.
11. Keep the appetizers light
A big appetizer spread is one of the quietest ways the bill goes up. And by the time dinner is on the table, everyone is already full.
A simple veggie tray, or one cheese with dip and maybe some nuts is plenty. Save the room (and the money) for the main event. You can also consider having the appetizers delegated to guests, leaving you to only focus on the main meal.
12. Make your own where it counts
We’re all for saving time during the holidays, but some things are better made at home than bought ready-made at the store.
- Brine: It’s literally salt, water, and a few spices. Skip the nicely packaged brining kits with the big markup. You can make your own for pennies, and a quick search for homemade brines will give you plenty to choose from.
- Gravy: Once you have the turkey, you have almost everything you need for a great gravy, plus a little flour or cornstarch and water. It’s cheaper, and it tastes so much better. Can’t face making gravy in those frenzied minutes before everyone sits down? Make it ahead with store-bought stock. Or do what I do and appoint a family member as your “Gravy Master,” so you can focus on getting everything to the table.
- Desserts: Making pies and baked goods at home is a great tradition to share with the kids, and a big money saver. Many desserts can be made a few days ahead. And if you’re short on time or baking isn’t your thing, dessert is one of the simplest things to hand off to a guest.
If you’re looking for a new dessert this year, our Sticky Date Pudding is always a favorite.
Start a little early
Most of these tips work best with some lead time. Make your list and send the menu to guests this week. Pick up shelf-stable items like stuffing mix, canned pumpkin, and baking supplies when they show up in the flyer, and save the fresh items for the last few days.
And skip the new decor. Pumpkins, candles, a string of lights here and there, and the dishes you already own make a beautiful table.
Remember, Thanksgiving is about creating memories with your family and friends, not just the food on the table. Whether you’re hosting a crowd or keeping it small this year, a little planning goes a long way toward saving money and stress.
And once the leftovers are gone, weeknight dinners will be waiting. If you want help getting dinners on the table that use your grocery store’s weekly sales and your dietary preferences, we can help. Try The Dinner Daily free for 14 days. After you select your preferences and your store, you’ll have a ready-to-go meal plan created just for you.
Updated November 2026








